A, B, or tie.
(prompt, A, B, winner) row is a raw pairwise comparison. Convert the winner into the chosen and rejected fields or other schema required by your reward-model or DPO trainer. Ties usually need separate handling.
Add a rationale
A rationale per comparison gives annotators something to audit and helps debug a noisy reward model.Compare against a rubric
When preference should follow explicit criteria, put the rubric in the instructions and keep the output constrained toA, B, or tie.